With those criteria in mind, here’s a closer look at how the leading tools compare.
1. Scribe from Headway: AI-assisted therapy notes inside a free, all-in-one practice platform
Headway is a free platform built specifically for insurance-based practices, and Scribe is its built-in AI note assistant. Rather than adding another subscription, Scribe comes bundled with the same free EHR that handles your credentialing, billing, scheduling, and telehealth, so you don’t need to manage or pay for a separate tool.
Scribe works two ways. You can write a brief session summary that Scribe can use to draft a full note, or, with the permission of you and your client, you can use it during a Headway Telehealth session so that Scribe can draft directly from the transcript.
Either option ends with a clawback-protected note so you can trust that your documentation is more consistent, more accurate, and more audit-ready.
Scribe’s highlights:
- AI-assisted progress notes: Scribe automatically generates a draft note from a session summary or Headway Telehealth transcript. Currently, Scribe is focused on 1:1 progress notes for talk therapists — not intake or other note types.
- Prioritizes the human touch: Providers always exercise their ability to review and edit notes at any point.
- Built-in clawback protection: Using Headway's payer-compliant templates, Scribe drafts notes that are structured around what insurers actually look for in documentation.
- Security and privacy from day one: Scribe is built with HIPAA- and SOC 2-compliance in mind and end-to-end encrypted, with one-time client consent required before transcription begins.
- Free to join: You’ll find Scribe included with Headway's EHR at no extra cost, with no separate subscription required.
2. Freed
Freed is a general AI medical scribe that also supports mental health and psychiatry as two of several specialties it covers, alongside family medicine, internal medicine, and others. It captures live or telehealth audio and drafts notes, with specialty-specific templates and a Chrome extension that can push notes into browser-based EHRs.
Freed's highlights:
- Broad specialty coverage: Supports mental health and psychiatry alongside many other specialties, which is useful for providers who work across disciplines.
- EHR integration on top-tier plans: Pushes notes directly into your EHR with one click, but be aware this feature is reserved for Freed’s most expensive plan.
Freed's limitations:
- Pricing scales with features: Entry-level plans cap the number of notes you can generate each month. You’ll need to move up the tier list to generate unlimited notes and access EHR push.
- Not mental health-specific: Templates cover many specialties rather than being built exclusively with therapy documentation in mind.
3. Mentalyc
Mentalyc is built specifically for mental health documentation, generating SOAP, DAP, and other note formats from recordings, dictation, uploads, or typed summaries. It offers several individual tiers plus a team plan, with features like session analytics and treatment plan support layered in as you move up.
Mentalyc's highlights:
- Deep format library: Higher tiers unlock 100 or more note formats, including BIRP, GIRP, PIE, and SIRP.
- Built-in BAA: A consent form and business associate agreement are included — even on the entry-level plan.
Mentalyc's limitations:
- Session-type support is tier-gated: Couples, family, and child therapy aren't available until you move up a couple of tiers. Group therapy requires the top individual plan.
- Note volume is capped by plan: Lower tiers limit how many notes you can generate each month, with unlimited notes available only on the per-seat team plan.
4. Upheal
Upheal has a free plan that covers unlimited notes from typed or dictated summaries, plus HIPAA-compliant telehealth. However, it won't generate notes from your actual session audio until you upgrade. The paid plan unlocks that feature, along with more note formats, session analytics, and AI-generated treatment plans.
Upheal's highlights:
- Free tier available: Unlimited notes from text or dictation, plus telehealth, at no cost.
- Pay per session (with a ceiling): You're charged per session, but the total is capped at a flat monthly maximum. So, a busier month won't cost more past that designated point.
Upheal's limitations:
- AI notes from audio require a paid plan: The free tier doesn't generate notes directly from session recordings.
- No native EHR push: Notes are designed to be copied into your practice's EHR rather than synced automatically.
5. Autonotes
Autonotes generates notes from typed summaries, dictation, or uploaded recordings, with live in-person and virtual session capture available on its higher tier. According to Autonotes' own Trust Center, it signs a business associate agreement with every customer using protected health information within the app.
Autonotes' highlights:
- Unlimited notes on every paid tier: Both paid plans include unlimited AI-generated notes.
- BAA included: One of these is signed for any customer using PHI in the app.
Autonotes' limitations:
- Live session recording requires a higher tier: The entry-level plan supports typed summaries, dictation, and uploads only. Live capture requires moving up a plan.
- Fewer analytics and admin tools than some competitors: Advanced analytics and team tools are reserved for the enterprise tier.
6. TheraPro
TheraPro offers a free tier with limited ambient session listening, plus paid tiers that expand session length, volume, and features like diagnostic assistance and treatment planning. A HIPAA business associate agreement is included as part of the standard sign-up process, and TheraPro maintains zero-data-retention agreements with its AI model providers.
TheraPro's highlights:
- Functional free tier: Includes a handful of full and typed sessions each week, with ambient listening included.
- BAA included by default: This is standard for all therapist sign-ups.
TheraPro's limitations:
- Session and note caps on lower tiers: Entry-level plans limit weekly session counts. Only the top tier offers unlimited sessions and length.
- SOC 2 certification is still pending: As of the date of this publication, TheraPro's site notes that SOC 2 certification is "coming.” It isn't completed yet, unlike some competitors that already hold it.